Jump to content

Vilna Gaon

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Elijah ben Solomon)
Elijah ben Solomon Zalman
TitleVilna Gaon
Elijah of Vilna
Gra
Personal life
Born
Elijah ben Solomon Zalman

April 23, 1720
DiedOctober 9, 1797 (aged 77)
NationalityPolish-Lithuanian
Religious life
ReligionJudaism
DenominationOrthodox Judaism
Yahrtzeit19 Tishrei
BuriedVilnius, Lithuania

Elijah ben Solomon Zalman,[1] (Hebrew: ר' אליהו בן שלמה זלמן Rabbi Eliyahu ben Shlomo Zalman), also known as the Vilna Gaon[2] (Yiddish: דער װילנער גאון Der Vilner Goen; Polish: Gaon z Wilna, Gaon Wileński; or Elijah of Vilna, or by his Hebrew acronym Gra ("Gaon Rabbenu Eliyahu": "Our great teacher Elijah"; Sialiec, April 23, 1720 – Vilnius October 9, 1797), was a Lithuanian Jewish Talmudist, halakhist, kabbalist, and the foremost leader of misnagdic (non-hasidic) Jewry of the past few centuries.[3][4][5] He is commonly referred to in Hebrew as ha-Gaon mi-Vilna, "the genius from Vilnius".[6]

Through his annotations and emendations of Talmudic and other texts, he became one of the most familiar and influential figures in rabbinic study since the Middle Ages. Although he is chronologically one of the Acharonim, some have considered him one of the Rishonim.[7][8][9]

Large groups of people, including many yeshivas, uphold the set of Jewish customs and rites (minhag), the "minhag ha-Gra", named after him, and which is also considered by many to be the prevailing Ashkenazi minhag in Jerusalem.

Born in Sielec in the Brest Litovsk Voivodeship (today Syalyets, Belarus), the Gaon displayed extraordinary talent while still a child. By the time he was twenty years old, rabbis were submitting their most difficult halakhic problems to him for legal rulings. He was a prolific author, writing such works as glosses on the Babylonian Talmud and Shulchan Aruch known as Bi'urei ha-Gra ("Elaborations by the Gra"), a running commentary on the Mishnah, Shenoth Eliyahu ("The Years of Elijah"), and insights on the Torah entitled Adereth Eliyahu ("The Cloak of Elijah"), published by his son. Various Kabbalistic works have commentaries in his name, and he wrote commentaries on the Proverbs and other books of the Tanakh later on in his life. None of his manuscripts were published in his lifetime.

When Hasidic Judaism became influential in his native town, the Vilna Gaon joined the "opposers" or Misnagdim, rabbis and heads of the Polish communities, to curb Hasidic influence.[10][11]

While he advocated studying branches of secular education such as mathematics in order to better understand rabbinic texts, he harshly condemned the study of philosophy and metaphysics.[12]

Biography

[edit]

Elijah was born to Treina and Rabbi Shlomo Zalman[13] in the village of Slać, near Brisk, now in Belarus, then in Lithuania, which was part of the Polish–Lithuanian Commonwealth, on 15 Nisan 5480 (April 23, 1720).[14]

His grandfather was Yissachar Dov,[15] the son of Rabbi Eliyahu Chassid,[16] after whom he was named. Rabbi Eliyahu Chassid was the son of Rabbi Moshe Kramer, rabbi of Vilna,[17] and his wife was the granddaughter of Rabbi Moshe Rivkes.[18]

Until the age of six, he studied under a rabbi. At that age, he delivered a derasha in the Great Synagogue of Vilna, which his father had taught him. At the request of Rabbi Heschel, the Av Beit Din of Vilna, he added his own scholarly discourse to demonstrate his ability to innovate independently.[19] His book Shnot Eliyahu[20] contains an insight he expressed at the age of seven. At this age, he lived for about three months in Kaidan with the town's rabbi, Rabbi David Katzenellenbogen, studying under him and Rabbi Moshe Margolies, author of Pnei Moshe on the Jerusalem Talmud (who later served as rabbi of Kaidan).[21] At age nine, he began studying Kabbalah,[22] devoting several hours daily to studying the Zohar and the writings of the Arizal. By age ten, he studied independently and no longer required teachers. During this time, he befriended Rabbi Aryeh Leib, later Av Beit Din of Tsechanovitz. From the age of eight, he engaged in astronomy.

As a young man, he married Chana, daughter of Yehuda Leib from Kaidan (1724–1782).[23] His wife took responsibility for managing the household so he could devote himself entirely to study. After her passing in 5543 (1783), he requested that the following be inscribed on her tombstone: "Chana passed away in 5543, 5 Kislev. She left no equal or comparison / There is no path or way to recount her praise." Later, he married Gitel, daughter of Meir Luntz from Chełm, who was also a widow.[24]

At around age 20, he traveled to Poland and Germany, passing through Leszno and Berlin, and possibly also Amsterdam. He returned to Vilna in 5505 (1745). Over the years, he lived in Vilna but consistently refused to hold an official rabbinic position that would interfere with his studies. Nevertheless, the Vilna community, considering it an honor to have him in their city, granted him a small monthly stipend for his livelihood.[25]

The Vilna Gaon became famous for his extraordinary diligence. His sons recount that throughout his life, he slept only two hours a day, divided into four half-hour segments,[26] ensuring he never slept more than "Sixty Breaths".[27] He dedicated all his time exclusively to Torah study. His student, Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, described how, when he was preoccupied with a Talmudic difficulty, he would refrain from eating for days until he found a resolution, appearing emaciated and afflicted.[28]

Status

[edit]

The Vilna Gaon attained an extraordinary and undisputed status during his lifetime. Among the general non-Hasidic public, his standing was considered exceptional. He was perceived as belonging to the ranks of the Tannaim and Amoraim, the sages of the Talmud, or as akin to the Geonim of Babylonia.[29]

Rabbi Avraham Yeshayahu Karelitz (the Chazon Ish) wrote about him:

We regard the Gaon of Vilna as belonging to the ranks of Moses, Ezra, Rabbeinu HaKadosh, Rav Ashi, and the Rambam. The Gaon, through whom Torah was revealed as a sanctified figure destined to illuminate that which had remained in darkness until his time, is considered one of the Rishonim. His level of Ruach HaKodesh (Divine inspiration), his toil, and his profound analytical knowledge of the entirety of Torah as we possess it today—these are beyond comprehension.[30]

Due to this reverence, he was referred to by Litvak Jewry simply as "the Gaon."

A portrait attributed to the Vilna Gaon
A street sign named after the Vilna Gaon in Vilnius
A commemorative plaque in Vilnius at the site where the Vilna Gaon's house once stood, inscribed: "The Gaon Eliyahu of Vilna lived in the house that stood here."
The place of the Great Synagogue and the Monument of Vilna Gaon, Vilnius

The Vilna Gaon advocated for a study approach focused on the peshat (literal meaning) and was himself widely knowledgeable and erudite. His in-law, the author of Chayei Adam, wrote about him:

The entire Torah was laid out before him like a set table, so that if he was asked about any matter, he would answer instantaneously.[31]

He opposed sharp dialectical analysis (pilpul) in learning, just as Maimonides, the Maharal, Rav Kook, and other Jewish sages did. In his small study hall, students learned Talmud with the commentaries of Rashi, the Rosh, and the Rif, in a straightforward manner aimed at reaching halachic conclusions.[32]

The Vilna Gaon was highly original in his halachic rulings and often ruled based on his own understanding of the Talmud, even against the Rishonim and the Shulchan Aruch, or in opposition to established customs.[33]

His learning was based on a deep pursuit of the literal meaning from the sources, as well as on textual emendations, especially in less commonly studied works such as the Jerusalem Talmud, the Tosefta, and the Zohar. Despite his historical significance to the Misnagdim, the method of study practiced in contemporary litvak yeshivas differs significantly from his approach. Most of his textual emendations were not based on manuscript evidence available to him but rather on his exceptional mastery of rabbinic and Talmudic literature. In retrospect, many of his emendations have been found to align with accurate textual witnesses.

On the evening following Yom Kippur, the Vilna Gaon would continue fasting for several more hours while studying Torah. He did this based on the teaching of the Sages:

What is the meaning of the verse: 'And it was evening, and it was morning, the sixth day' (Genesis 1:31)? Why is the extra 'the' needed? This teaches that God made a condition with the works of creation, saying: If Israel accepts the Torah, you will continue to exist; but if not, I will return you to chaos and void.[34]

In other words, the world’s existence depends on uninterrupted Torah study. Since, on the night after Yom Kippur, everyone went home to eat, the Vilna Gaon would continue learning until people finished their meals and returned to study. This idea also served as the foundation of Volozhin Yeshiva, established by his disciple, Rabbi Chaim.

Kabbalah in his teachings

[edit]

By the age of nine, the Vilna Gaon knew all of Tanach and Shas with commentaries, and had already begun studying Kabbalah.[35]

The Gaon wrote commentaries on Sifra de-Tzeniuta, which he regarded as the foundational work of Kabbalah, as well as on Tikkunei Zohar, Tikkunei Zohar Chadash, and other sections of the Zohar, as well as on Sefer Yetzirah.

However, unlike other Kabbalists, the Gaon opposed the reception of maggid revelations, as he wished to toil in Torah study and receive divine wisdom directly from God rather than through intermediaries. He also sent his disciple, Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, to warn his brother, Rabbi Shlomo Zalman of Volozhin, not to accept a maggid that was destined to appear to him, explaining that the maggidim of that generation, particularly outside the Land of Israel, "could not possibly be entirely sacred and free of any impurity."[36]

The teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Kabbalah are considered a distinct stream (although they are sometimes integrated with the teachings of Ramchal), and many Kabbalists have studied and interpreted them, such as his disciples: Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin in his book Nefesh HaChaim, Rabbi Moshe of Tolchin, Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Shklov, and the disciples of his disciples, Rabbi Yitzhak Isaac Chever, Rabbi David Luria, Rabbi Avraham Simcha of Amchislav, Rabbi Elijah of Kalish, as well as Rabbi Shlomo Elyashiv in his book Leshem Shevo VeAchlamah, Rabbi Naftali Herz Halevy of Jaffa, and others.

In our generation, the writings of the Vilna Gaon have been studied by Rabbi Yitzhak Shlomo Zilberman, Rabbi Sharya Dublitzky, Rabbi Israel Eliyahu Winterob, Rabbi Yaakov Edes (Divrei Yaakov),[37] and Rabbi Yosef Avivi, who also wrote a special book explaining the uniqueness of the Vilna Gaon’s Kabbalah and the differences between it and the Kabbalah of Arizal.

During the struggle between the Hasidim and the Misnagdim, the Hasidim spread a rumor that the Vilna Gaon did not believe in the teachings of Kabbalah and did not engage in the Zohar or the writings of Arizal. By doing so, they sought to undermine the Gaon’s opposition to Hasidism.[38] The Vilna Gaon’s disciple, Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, in his introduction to the Vilna Gaon’s commentary on Sifra D’Tzeniuta, sharply criticizes those who spread the rumor, with the following words:

And whenever I speak of the greatness and wonders of the holiness of the teachings of our great Rabbi, may his soul rest in peace, I remember and recall with great anguish that my soul is stirred and burned with a fire within me. For I heard many false reports from empty fools in distant provinces, who had never seen the light of his teachings or his holiness. Those without burden in speech and tongue speak of great things to defame the sanctities of Heaven. Like flies of death who seek to spoil and defile the holy oil of our great Rabbi, may his soul rest in peace. They say that the holy Rabbi did not consider the spirit of holiness in the teachings of the Arizal to be of any worth, God forbid. And even further, some speak maliciously, claiming that the holy Zohar was not worthy in his eyes, Heaven forbid, to be the subject of his study. May the lips of falsehood be stilled, and the liars be silenced. Such things shall not be among the people of Israel.

The teachings of redemption in his doctrine

[edit]

According to the book Kol HaTor, which some attribute to Rabbi Hillel Rivlin of Shklov, in the year 1740 (the Hebrew year 5500), the Gaon began his open engagement with Kabbalah. According to his views on the Redemption, the year 5500 marks the beginning of the “sixth day” of the world, in which preparations should be made for the Sabbath, when the complete redemption will come. This calculation is based on the words of the Talmud in Sanhedrin (Sanhedrin 38b), which states that the world will exist for six thousand years. The Gaon considered each millennium as a day, based on the verse "For a thousand years in Your eyes are but as yesterday when it passes",[39] meaning that the year 5500 is the morning of the sixth day. Just as the Halakhah requires one to rise early on Friday and prepare for the Sabbath, so, according to the Gaon’s words, one should prepare for the “Sabbath” of the world starting from the “morning of the sixth day.”[40]

A new Shulchan Aruch

[edit]

According to what was written by the Gaon’s son, the Gaon intended to compose a new version of the Shulchan Aruch:

These two things I heard from his holy and pure mouth that he did not agree with his Creator’s opinion, and he did not do them. In his old age, I asked him many times why he did not travel to the Holy Land, and he did not answer me. And he promised me that he would write halakhic rulings from the Arba'ah Turim with a decisive opinion, writing only the one opinion that seemed correct to his wisdom, with strong and unanswerable proofs.

— From the introduction to the Shulchan AruchOrach Chaim, Shklov, 1803

His attitude towards secular studies and philosophy

[edit]
The book "Euclid's Elements," translated at the Gaon’s encouragement

The Gaon supported secular studies, which included some of the sciences, primarily the natural sciences, and even wrote a book on mathematics, astronomy, and geometry titled Il Mishulash. In the introduction to the translation of Euclid’s Elements (translated into Hebrew by Rabbi Baruch Shklov in The Hague in 1780), it is quoted in his name:

Just as a person will lack knowledge of other wisdoms, so too will they be missing a hundredfold in the wisdom of Torah… And he commanded me (= the Gaon) to translate from what we can of these wisdoms into our holy tongue in order to remove the poison from their mouths, and many will be enlightened, and knowledge will increase among the people of Israel.

The words of Rabbi Baruch Shik are supported by a translation written by the Vilna Gaon's son, Rabbi Avraham Vilner, of parts of the Natural History by the radical French scientist Georges-Louis Leclerc, Comte de Buffon.[41]

According to the testimony of his disciples and the books written in his name, the Gaon was knowledgeable in mathematics, engineering, biology, astronomy, geography, linguistics, and music, but he refrained from engaging in pharmacy based on his father's instructions.[42]

He also studied human philosophy but opposed the study of general humanities because he did not see them as having true value for Jewish life. The Gaon distinguished between the humanities and the natural sciences, which he saw as "pharmacology and medicine" assisting in the understanding of the Torah.[43]

Rabbi Yisrael Shklov recounts the Gaon’s teachings:

Thus he said, all wisdoms are necessary for our Torah... and are included in it, and all must be known to their purpose, and he mentioned them: the wisdom of algebra, triangles, and engineering and the wisdom of music... And he explained the nature of all the wisdoms and said that he had attained them for their purpose, except for the wisdom of medicine, he knew the science of surgery and its connection to it, but he was forbidden by his father to study the practice of medicines and their work, so as not to be distracted from his Torah study when he would be required to go and save lives, once he knew it fully. Likewise, the wisdom of witchcraft... and he knew it, but he was lacking in the practice of herbs and all their workings, because they were in the hands of the Gentiles who are heretics, and thus he could not learn their full practice due to his strong commitment.

— P'atei HaShulchan, Introduction, Speech Starting: "And an extended explanation on its side"

In contrast to his view on natural sciences, he strongly opposed philosophy and its practitioners, as stated in the book "Even Shlomo" (a compilation of his writings) in chapter 11, section 4. He said:

Blessed are those who distance themselves from those who engage in the study of divine, logical, and natural philosophy. They will merit, in the future, to the light of God (Isaiah 2:6).

In a footnote there, it is further mentioned regarding this passage:

See in Yoreh De'ah, section 319, small section 13, where he also condemned false philosophy, and see in the book Aliyot Eliyahu 17:2. And contrary to those who say that what he wrote in Yoreh De'ah in the aforementioned section is not from the Gaon. I heard from a trusted person that it is indeed found in his handwriting exactly as demonstrated here. And see Yoreh De'ah, section 456, small section 18.

In his commentary on the Book of Isaiah, chapter 2, verse 6, the Gaon wrote: "For you have forsaken your people" – meaning, for the merit of having forsaken your people, as it is written: "Forget your people and the house of your father, and the king will desire your beauty."(Tanakh, Psalms, 41, 11, 12)}}

"For they are full of old" – meaning, for your people being full of old, that is why you forsook your people and merited the light of God. And he said "old" refers to the divine, as it is written: "The habitation of the God of old." (Tanakh, Deuteronomy, 33, 27}}

"And clouds" refers to those who know how to determine times, as in "The astrologers of the heavens." (Tanakh, Isaiah, 47, 13}}

"And children of strangers" refers to natural philosophy.

The Vilna Gaon's commentary on Yoreh De'ah, section 319, subsection 6, small subsection 13:

The Rambam... followed philosophy, and therefore he wrote that witchcraft, names, incantations, demons, and amulets are all false. But they have struck him on his head, for we find many stories in the Talmud regarding names and witchcraft... And philosophy misled him, for in the majority, it took him to interpret the Talmud in a derisive way and to uproot them from their simple meaning. God forbid, I do not believe in them, nor in their sources, nor in their power. Rather, all these things are as their simple meaning, but there is a deeper meaning not of the philosophers, which is superficial, but of the people of truth.

— Yeshu'ah D'ra'ah (Vilna Gaon’s Commentary on Yoreh De'ah, 319, 6, subsection 13)

Some saw his favorable attitude towards secular studies as the reason for the spread of the Haskala in Lithuania more than in Hasidic Poland. This claim was refuted in later research.[44]

Attempt to make Aliyah to the land of Israel

[edit]
A common portrait of the Vilna Gaon

It is known that the Vilna Gaon tried to immigrate to the Land of Israel, and even wrote a letter to his family while traveling to Königsberg, which was later published under the title "Aliyah to Terufah." In the letter, he wrote that he was going to the "desired Land of Israel and the desire of God, whose upper and lower realms yearn for it." However, this attempt was unsuccessful, and he decided to return home, stating that he had no permission from heaven to make aliyah to the Land of Israel.[45]

There is disagreement regarding the year in which the Vilna Gaon tried to make aliyah. Dov Eliyach, in his book "The Gaon," tries to prove from the wording of the letter that the attempt occurred when the Gaon was around forty years old, likely in the winter of Tavkuf Kaf (1759 (1759)–1760 (1760)). The book 'Kol HaTor' states that he attempted to make aliyah in the year Tavmem Bet (1782 (1782)). In contrast, Dr. Aryeh Morgenstern argues that the attempt occurred around the year Tavkuf Lamed Chet (1778 (1778)), based on documents from the Jewish community in Holland mentioning a person named "Rabbi Eliyahu from Vilna," although it is unclear whether this refers to the Gaon. Eli Eliyach suggested that the attempt took place in the summer of the year Tavkuf Zayin (1767 (1767)).[46]

As described in the book Kol HaTor, the Vilna Gaon sought to renew the Jewish settlement in the Land of Israel, to revive its desolate areas, and to create a group of wise and moral individuals whom he called "Anshei Emunah" (People of Faith). He believed this would pave the way for the arrival of the Messiah, whom he anticipated would appear in the year Tav Resh (1840 (1840)). He proclaimed, "The voice of the turtle dove is heard in our land" (based on Song of Songs 2:12).

Following his teachings and through the initiative of his disciple Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, many of his students made aliyah to the Land of Israel beginning in the year Tav Kaf Chet (1808 (1808)), in the aliyah known as the "Aliyat Talmidei HaGra" led by his disciple Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Shklov. Initially, they settled in Safed and established the Perushim community there. From the year Tav Kuf Ayin Vav (1816 (1816)), some of them moved to Jerusalem and re-established the Ashkenazi community there.[47]

Opposition to Hasidism

[edit]
A statue of the Vilna Gaon where his house once stood in Vilnius

The Vilna Gaon opposed the Hasidic movement[48] due to various distortions he saw in it, which led him to classify it as heresy and a movement stemming from impurity. As early as the year Tav Kuf Lamed Bet (1772 (1772)), the Gaon's signature appeared on the excommunication decree of the Vilna community against Hasidism. In the year Tav Kuf Mem Aleph (1781 (1781)), he issued another excommunication. He refused to meet with the founder of the Chabad Hasidic movement, Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi, and instructed that the book Tzav HaRivash be publicly burned.[49]

There are various opinions regarding the distortions the Gaon saw in Hasidism. Shimon Dubnov argued that Hasidism threatened the communal structure of the rabbinic Jewish faith by placing emotion before reason, in addition to concerns that it was a new messianic movement rising against Judaism. Others argued that Hasidism was perceived as a frivolous movement that mocked Torah scholars who opposed it, accompanied by actions viewed as lighthearted, such as disrespect for prayer times, standing on one's head, and more. Rabbi Joseph Dov Halevi Soloveitchik of Boston added that the Gaon saw Hasidism spreading rapidly, which caused him to fear that it was "the work of Satan," as holiness usually spreads slowly.

Some claim that the opposition stemmed from the Gaon's belief that Hasidism contained elements that differed from the Jewish faith as it had been accepted until then. In a letter from the Gaon, he referred to Hasidism as the worship of wood and stone, a statement that indicates the theological aspect of his opposition to Hasidism, identifying it as deviating from the fundamentals of Jewish faith. He may have meant the oversimplification of complex Kabbalistic ideas, such as the presence of God in the physical world and the existence of "Nitzotzot" (holy sparks) in the world, even in simple things like trees and stones, for the purpose of "clarifying the sparks," a central concept in Hasidic thought. There may also be a hint to his suspicions that Hasidism continued or resembled dangerous heresy and antinomianism, as seen in the Shabbatean and Frankist movements.

In a letter from Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi to his followers in Vilna, he mentions that the Gaon's opposition to him stemmed from a disagreement on defining the presence of God in the physical world.[50]

His students

[edit]

The Vilna Gaon did not have students in the usual sense of the word and did not serve as the head of a yeshiva. However, in the winter of Tav Kuf Mem Ches (1767 (1767)), he established a beit midrash adjacent to his home, where he occasionally gave lectures, primarily in his youth, and where select Torah scholars studied. They would present their questions and doubts before him. His students felt the immense gap between themselves and him and refused to be called his "students". The Gaon's sons, in the introduction to the Gaon's commentary on the Shulchan Aruch, compiled a list of some of his distinguished students:

  • Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin – Considered his greatest student, he established the Volozhin Yeshiva, the central yeshiva in Europe, and wrote the book Nefesh HaChaim, in part as a polemic against the Hasidic movement.
  • Rabbi Shlomo Av Beit Din of Vilkomir[51]
  • Rabbi Shlomo Zalman of Volozhin – Brother of Rabbi Chaim.
  • Rabbi Shlomo of Tolchin – One of his first students to immigrate to Israel while the Gaon was still alive.
  • Rabbi Saadia – Brother-in-law of Rabbi Shlomo Zalman of Volozhin, a leader of the Aliyah of the Gaon's Students. He served the Gaon and wrote down his conduct, which was later published in the book Maaseh Rav, and was his emissary in the struggle against Hasidism.
  • Rabbi Moshe Shlomo of Tolchin – A preacher in the community of Vilna, a close disciple of the Gaon in Kabbalah, and an editor of some of his writings.
  • Rabbi Tzvi Hirsch of Smiatits.
  • Rabbi Shlomo of Mohilev.
  • Rabbi Benjamin Rivlin.

The Gaon's sons write that in his later years, two brothers from Shklov, Rabbi Binyamin and Rabbi Menachem Mendel, came closer to him:

  • Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Shklov served the Gaon during his last two years and was one of the leaders of the Aliyah of the Gaon's Students to Israel, founding the Ashkenazi community in Jerusalem.
  • Rabbi Menasha of Ilya – Author of the book "Alfei Menashe." Known for his work in science and original philosophical views.
  • Rabbi Jacob Kahana – Son-in-law of Rabbi Yissachar Ber, the Gaon's brother.
  • Rabbi Pinchas ben Yehuda Altshul (Pinchas of Płock) – A preacher, author of several books.
  • Rabbi Menachem Mendel – Author of the book "Tammim Yachdav," a preacher in the community of Ponevezh.[52]
  • Rabbi Israel of Shklov – Served the Gaon during the last six months of his life, one of the leaders of the Aliyah of the Gaon's Students, author of the book Peat HaShulchan and a commentary on Tractate Shekalim, and an editor of several of the Gaon's works.
  • Rabbi Hillel Rivlin of Shklov, son of Rabbi Benjamin – One of the immigrants in the Aliyah of the Gaon's Students in the year Tav Kuf Samech Bet (1832 (1832)). The book Kol HaTor is attributed to him, although some claim he was not a student of the Gaon.
  • Rabbi Yehuda Leib Halevi Adel of Slonim – An expert in Hebrew grammar who assisted the Gaon in writing his books.[53]
  • Rabbi Chiel Michal of Minsk[54]

His writings

[edit]

The teachings of the Vilna Gaon were published in books covering many areas of Torah, including commentaries on the Torah, the Prophets, the Megillot, the book of Chronicles, Mishnahs from Zeraim and Taharot, explanations of the Jerusalem Talmud, Tosefta, Minor Tractates, Torat Kohanim, and more. In the realm of Kabbalah, his teachings include commentaries on parts of the Zohar, Sifra de-Tzeniuta, Heikhalot, and the Sefer Yetzirah, among others. The Vilna Gaon also frequently explained Midrashim through the lens of Kabbalah.[55]

According to the words of Rabbi Israel of Shklov, it is believed that the Gaon wrote all his works up to the age of 40 (except for the glosses on all of the Talmudic literature). After this, he lectured to his students or dictated his teachings to them.[56]

The bibliographer Isaiah Winer compiled a complete book Treasury of the Vilna Gaon’s Books in which he gathered all the Vilna Gaon’s works in their editions as they were printed until the year Tav Shin Nun Chet (1998 (1998)). Some of his books have recently been edited in a clearer and annotated form by Rabbi Shlomo Bravda.

His student, Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, writes:

"Even if the generation merits that all of his holy writings be spread, nevertheless, only a small part of his vast wisdom and knowledge will be seen, and none will fully comprehend it. But know and believe that there is no limit to his understanding, wisdom, and knowledge, which is as vast as the sea. And just as a drop is compared to the vast ocean, so too are his writings compared to his abundant wisdom."[57]

His family

[edit]

The Vilna Gaon was the eldest of his siblings and had four brothers:[58]

  • Rabbi Moshe, preacher and Mo"tz in the town of Podzelova near Vilkomir
  • Rabbi Abraham, author of "Ma'alot HaTorah", preacher in Shklov and rabbi in Rogula, passed away on 4 Nisan 1804 (1804)
  • Rabbi Yitzhak Ber, one of the prominent scholars of Vilna, authored several books,[59] passed away on 9 Elul 1806 (1806).[60] His son-in-law was Rabbi Yaakov Kohen a student of the Gaon
  • Rabbi Meir, from the community of Yanushuk, whom the Gaon referred to as "The Light that Shines"

All eight of the Vilna Gaon’s children were born to his first wife, Chana:

  • Daughter (name unknown) (1741–1756), passed away in her youth
  • China (1748–1806), married Rabbi Zalman Zelig Chinitz of Pinsk and after his death married Rabbi Moshe of Pinsk, who printed several of his father-in-law's books
  • Pesia Batya (born 1750 (1750)), married Tzvi Hirsch Donchin of Dissna
  • Daughter (name unknown) (born 1752 (1752)), married Yizchak Eliezer Halevi
  • Shlomo Zalman Vilner (1759–1780)
  • Yehuda Leib Vilner (1764–1816)
  • Rabbi Abraham Ben HaVilna Gaon (Abraham Vilner) (1765–1808)
  • Taube (1768–1812), married Rabbi Uri Shraga Feibush of Doberovne

Among his more notable descendants in recent times is Rabbi Eliyahu Landa.[61][62][63]

Commemoration

[edit]
The tomb of the Vilna Gaon and Abraham ben Abraham

Synagogues have been established in the name of the Vilna Gaon, particularly in the Shaarei Chesed neighborhood in Jerusalem. In addition, Yeshivat HaGra (now Kollel Avrechim) in Haifa, Yeshivat Aderet Eliyahu and Kehillat Aderet Eliyahu in the Old City of Jerusalem were founded in his name, aiming to follow his path.

Portraits of the Vilna Gaon began to be published as lithographs between the years 1821–1825. The original artist was the head of the lithographic department at the University of Vilna, the Lithuanian-Polish artist Joseph Hilary Globzicki.[64]

In 1999 (1999), the Government of Israel requested to bring the Vilna Gaon’s remains to Israel, but the request was denied by the Lithuanian government, partly due to the opposition of the Jewish community there.[65]

The year 2020, marking the 300th anniversary of the Gaon’s birth, was declared by the Lithuanian Parliament as the Year of the Vilna Gaon and the Year of Jewish History.[66][67][68] In the same year, the Vilna Gaon Museum of Jewish History in Lithuania was named in his honor.[69]

The HaGra Institute for the publication of his writings

[edit]

In the 1990s (1990s), the HaGra World Institute was established in Bnei Brak (Israel) and New York (United States) to print his books and writings with innovations and explanations of his teachings, as well as the publication of the writings of his HaGra students and their yeshivas, led by the descendants of Rabbi Yerucham Fishel Pepper, the brothers Rabbi Nehemiah Pepper and Rabbi Shmuel Yaakov Pepper.

Further reading

[edit]
  • Elazar Horowitz (editor), Mikdash HaYesod – History of the Early Jewish Settlement in Jerusalem by the Students of the Vilna Gaon, General Committee of the Knesset Israel Publishing, First Edition: 1958 (1958); Expanded Second Edition: 2000 (2000)
  • Betzalel Landoy, The Hasidic Gaon of Vilna, 1965 (1965)
  • Yosef Avivi, The Kabbalah of the Vilna Gaon, 1993 (1993)
  • Emmanuel Atkes, Unique in His Generation: The Vilna Gaon – Personality and Image, Jerusalem: Zalman Shazar Center for Jewish History, 1998 (1998)
  • Aryeh Morgenstern, Mysticism and Messianism, from the Rise of the Ramchal to the Vilna Gaon, 1999 (1999)
  • Dov Elyach, The Gaon – His Life and Teachings, Vols. 1–3, "Moreshet HaYeshivot" Institute, 2002 (2002) – This book was banned among the Hasidic community because it included severe attacks on Hasidism,[70] however, it is accepted in the litvak community.
  • Research Compilation, The Vilna Gaon and His Yeshiva, Bar-Ilan University Press, 2003 (2003)
  • Aryeh Morgenstern, Return to Jerusalem, The Renewal of Jewish Settlement in the Land of Israel in the Early 19th Century, 2007 (2007)
  • Rafael B. Shochet, Hidden World in the Dimensions of Time – The Vilna Gaon’s Teachings of Redemption, Its Sources, and Its Impact for Generations, Bar-Ilan University Press, May 2008
  • David Kaminski, The Teachings of the Vilna Gaon, Pirkei Eliezer Institute, Jerusalem: 2018 (2018)
  • Moshe Tzuriel, Treasures of the Vilna Gaon – A Collection on His Ways and Teachings
  • Israel A. Shapira, Schools of Thought in the Question of Torah and Science in the Vilna Gaon's Yeshiva, Bet Din 13, Bar-Ilan University Press, 2003

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ Within recent decades he has been given the surname Kremer. However neither the Vilna Gaon nor his descendants apparently used this surname, which means shopkeeper. It was possibly mistakenly derived from a nickname of his ancestor Rabbi Moshe Kremer. "The Vilna Gaon, part 3 (Review of Eliyahu Stern, The Genius)". Marc B. Shapiro. The Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth census of 1765 (see image) refers to the Vilna Gaon as "Eliasz Zelmanowiz", probably because his father's name was "Zalman" (see here for an explanation of the suffix "-witz"). Ben-Ghedalia, Dr. Yochai (January 30, 2020). "The Vilna Gaon Makes a Surprise Appearance". The Librarians. Retrieved January 27, 2025.
  2. ^ Yaniv, Samuel (Rabbi) (April 17, 2010). "The Vilna Gaon and his Vision of Redemption". Bar Ilan University. Archived from the original on March 23, 2017. Retrieved May 19, 2012.
  3. ^ Etkes, Immanuel; Green, Jeffrey M. (2002). The Gaon of Vilna: The Man and His Image. University of California Press. ISBN 978-0-520-22394-3. JSTOR 10.1525/j.ctt1pnj2v.
  4. ^ Cohn-Sherbok, Dan; Cohn-Sherbok, Lavinia (1994). Jewish & Christian Mysticism: An Introduction. Gracewing Publishing. ISBN 978-0-85244-259-3.
  5. ^ Eisenberg, Ronald L. (December 1, 2011). Dictionary of Jewish Terms: A Guide to the Language of Judaism. Taylor Trade Publications. ISBN 978-1-58979-729-1.
  6. ^ The Threefold step of Academia Europeana: a case of Universitas Vilnensis, 2009, p. 24
  7. ^ Karelitz, Avraham Yeshaya. קובץ איגרות חזון איש [Collected letters of the 'Chazon Ish'] (in Hebrew). pp. Part one, section 32. אנו מתייחסים להגר"א בשורה של משה רבנו, עזרא, רבנו הקדוש, רב אשי והרמב"ם. הגר"א שנתגלה תורה על ידו כקדוש מעותד לכך שהאיר במה שלא הואר עד שבא ונטל חלקו, והוא נחשב אחד מהראשונים,
  8. ^ Danzig, Abraham. זכרו תורת משה (in Hebrew). p. 31. רבי אליהו חסיד, הוא היה עיר וקדיש כאחד מן הראשונים
  9. ^ Tzuzmir, Yekuseil A.Z.H (1882). שו"ת מהריא"ז ענזיל (in Hebrew). Lvov. pp. 40b. ומהר"א מווילנא אשר כחו כאחד הראשונים{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  10. ^ Bloomberg, Jon (2004). The Jewish world in the modern age. Jersey City, NJ: KTAV Publishing House. ISBN 978-0-88125-844-8.
  11. ^ Etkes, Immanuel (2002-05-30), "The Vilna Gaon and the Mitnagdim as Seen by the Hasidim", The Gaon of VilnaThe Man and His Image, University of California Press, pp. 96–150, doi:10.1525/california/9780520223943.003.0005, ISBN 978-0-520-22394-3, retrieved 2024-07-27
  12. ^ "Shulchan Arukh, Yoreh De'ah 179:6". www.sefaria.org. Retrieved 2023-12-30.
  13. ^ Rabbi Shlomo Zalman passed away on 25 Kislev 5519 (from the book Kiryah Ne'emanah, Vilna 1915, by Shmuel Finn, p. 128).
  14. ^ Yehoshua Heschel Levin, Aliyot Eliyahu, p. 27. In note 2, he proves that the year 5482, which appears in the introduction by the Vilna Gaon's sons to his commentary on the Shulchan Aruch, is a printing error.
  15. ^ #24 in the book Mishpachat Rivlin. He passed away on 9 Adar 5496, as mentioned in Ma'alot HaTorah (1942), p. 2.
  16. ^ Passed away on 21 Elul 5470, Kiryah Ne'emanah, by Shmuel Finn, Vilna 1915, p. 99, from the gravestone.
  17. ^ Passed away on 12 Cheshvan 5448. See the introduction to the book Rosh Yosef, by his son-in-law Rabbi Yosef, Av Beit Din of Seltz and Tykocin.
  18. ^ HebrewBooks, Be'er HaGolah, 24323, First edition, Amsterdam 1662
  19. ^ Introduction by the Vilna Gaon's sons to his commentary on the Shulchan Aruch.
  20. ^ Berakhot, Chapter 1, Mishnah 1, beginning "VeChachamim Omrim Ad Chatzot," and see the words of his son-in-law there.
  21. ^ Dov Eliach, HaGaon, Vol. 1, p. 73.
  22. ^ Introduction by his sons to his commentary on the Vilna Gaon and their introduction to Pirush al Kama Aggadot.
  23. ^ Geula Book - Vilna Gaon: Rabbi Eliyahu ben Shlomo Zalman
  24. ^ Easy Banner - Vilna Gaon
  25. ^ Schechter, Solomon; Seligsohn, M. "ELIJAH BEN SOLOMON (also called Elijah Wilna, Elijah Gaon, and Der Wilner Gaon)". Jewish Encyclopedia.
  26. ^ Introduction by his sons to Shulchan Aruch.
  27. ^ Menucha U'Kedusha, introduction to Shaar HaTorah Part II (p. 52, Vilna 1864 edition), Daat Noteh on the laws of Netilat Yadayim, p. 279.
  28. ^ Betemunah - The Gaon of Vilna: The Man and His Image (PDF)
  29. ^ Immanuel Etkes, Yachid BeDoro, Introduction, p. 9.
  30. ^ Kovetz Igrot Chazon Ish, Part I, Siman 32. Similarly, in Ketav VeHaKabbalah, in his letter at the beginning of the book Aliyot Eliyahu, he writes: "The awe-inspiring Gaon, like one of the Rishonim, our master Eliyahu of Vilna." Likewise, in Responsa Mahari’az Enzil, Siman 37 (by a student of the Ketzot HaChoshen and Av Beit Din of Stryi in Galicia), he lists a series of early halachic authorities and notes: "And Rabbi Eliyahu of Vilna, whose strength was like one of the Rishonim." Rabbi Avraham Danzig wrote in his introduction to the book Zichru Torat Moshe:

    We were privileged to see with our own eyes our master, the great and holy Gaon of Israel, Rabbi Eliyahu Chassid. He was an irreplaceable saint, like one of the Rishonim, and all the qualities that the Sages attributed to a Torah scholar were manifest in him—whether in Torah, in piety, or in his conduct, his vast knowledge...

  31. ^ See also Chut HaMeshulash responsa by Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, end of Siman 17.
  32. ^ Yeshivat Har Etzion - Surveying Previous Research on the Vilna Gaon’s Commentary and Its Impact
  33. ^ National Library of Israel - Vilna Gaon
  34. ^ Bavli, Shabbat, 88a
  35. ^ Study Booklets - Gra, Chassidim, and Great Rivalries (PDF)
  36. ^ Introduction of Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin to the Vilna Gaon's commentary on Sifra de-Tzeniuta.
  37. ^ Divrei Yaakov – Kabbalah of the Vilna Gaon, Part 1, Divrei Yaakov – Kabbalah of the Vilna Gaon, Part 2.
  38. ^ Torah Musings - Is Chabad Heresy?
  39. ^ Tanakh, Psalms, 90, 4
  40. ^ Mesorah Matrix - The Sanctity of Time by Shlomo Riskin (PDF)
  41. ^ I Idelson-Shein, "Their Eyes Shall Behold Strange Things": Abraham Ben Elijah of Vilna Encounters the Spirit of Mr. Buffon," AJS Review, Vol. 36, Issue 2 (2012), pp. 295-322 http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?fromPage=online&aid=8749263
  42. ^ Matthews, Michael R. (2014). International Handbook of Research in History, Philosophy and Science Teaching. Springer. ISBN 978-94-007-7654-8.
  43. ^ See Professor Shreiber’s article Bd"D 9 pages 5-28, and Bd"D 10, pages 5-16.
  44. ^ Emmanuel Atkes, Unique in His Generation, Chapter Two – The Vilna Gaon and the Haskalah
  45. ^ https://en.vilna.co.il/association-activities/books/%D7%94%D7%92%D7%90%D7%95%D7%9F-%D7%9E%D7%95%D7%95%D7%99the-vilna-gaon-and-his-historical-influence-on-hastening-the-redemption/. {{cite web}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)
  46. ^ Eli Eliyach, Academia.edu, HaGaon MiVilna - Anthology, 2020, pages 59-52.
  47. ^ "Two Hundred Years in Eretz Yisrael: The Seminal Aliyah of the Talmidei HaGra". Jewish Action. Retrieved 2025-01-29.
  48. ^ For his role in the dispute and its nature, see Dov Elyach's book The Gaon Part 3, and David Kaminetsky's articles in Yeshurun. Yehoshua Mondschein in his articles claims that the leaders of Vilna misled the Gaon to oppose Hasidism, and after his passing, they resorted to even more violent measures.
  49. ^ "Ba'al HaTanya and Vilna Gaon – Charges and Countercharges". Kotzk Blog. July 2016. Retrieved 2025-01-29.
  50. ^ "Cedars of Lebanon: The Tanya and the Gaon". Commentary Magazine. Retrieved 2025-01-29.
  51. ^ HibruBooks, Eliezer Cohen Ke"tzaman, Yeshurun, 20409, page 228, chapter R. Y. H.
  52. ^ HibruBooks, Eliezer Cohen Ke"tzaman, Yeshurun, 20308, page 377, chapter Shas5, title: To the Character of R. Menachem Mendel – A Student of the Gaon
  53. ^ BookSource, author=Yehuda Leib Halevi Adel, title=Haggadah Shel Pesach Mi Megiddo, publisher=Bnei Moshe Institute, year=1997, chapter=Introduction by the Publisher
  54. ^ Betzalel Landau, The Hasidic Gaon of Vilna, p. 263
  55. ^ "Vilna Gaon – Notable Sources". Sefaria. Retrieved 2025-01-29.
  56. ^ "Chapter 6.6: The Plain Meaning of the Mishna and Its Interpretation in the Gemara". Yeshivat Har Etzion. Retrieved 2025-01-29.
  57. ^ Introduction to the book Shnot Eliyahu
  58. ^ Details about the Gaon's brothers from – Dov Elyach, "The Gaon," Part I, pages 67-68
  59. ^ "Tzuf Dvash" on the Torah (currently in the National Library), and compositions on the Tanakh, Talmud, and Shulchan Aruch, which remain in manuscript and were burned in Volozhin
  60. ^ His grave was transferred along with the Gaon’s to the new cemetery, and his tombstone is still inside the Gaon’s tent. Also on him: Rabbi Tzvi Leivi Horowitz in The Writings of the Geonim (Second Edition, Petrikow, 1928 (1928), page 8, note [d]. He was the son-in-law of Rabbi Asher Ginzburg of Vilna
  61. ^ "The Vilna Gaon reexamined". The Jerusalem Post.
  62. ^ Chaim Freedman (1997). Eliyahu's Branches: The Descendants of the Vilna Gaon (of Blessed and Saintly Memory) and His Family. Avotaynu.
  63. ^ Chaim Freedman (2018-08-23). "Eliyahu's Branches: Genetic master list for relatives of the Vilna Gaon". Eliyahu's Branches. Retrieved 2024-05-15.
  64. ^ Eliyahu Ashd (2019-02-27). "The Portrait of the Vilna Gaon – Fake or Real?". The Multiverse of Eli Ashd. Retrieved 2020-08-27.
  65. ^ "Lithuanian Government Refuses to Transfer the Vilna Gaon's Remains". Kikar Shabbat. February 14, 1999. Retrieved 2025-01-29.
  66. ^ "The Year of the Vilna Gaon". Aish.com. Retrieved 2025-01-29.
  67. ^ "Official Announcement from the Seimas of the Republic of Lithuania". Seimas of the Republic of Lithuania. Retrieved 2025-01-29.
  68. ^ "Lithuanian Parliament Names 2020 the Year of the Vilna Gaon and Lithuanian Jewish History". Lithuanian Jewish Community. 2018-05-14. Retrieved 2025-01-29.
  69. ^ "Vilna Gaon State Jewish Museum". EHRI Project. Retrieved 2025-01-29.
  70. ^ "HaGaon". Books Blog. 2006–2007. Archived from the original on 2014-01-03. Retrieved 2025-01-29.

Bibliography

[edit]
  • Ackerman, C. D. (trans.) Even Sheleimah: the Vilna Gaon looks at life (Targum Press, 1994) ISBN 0-944070-96-5
  • Etkes, Immanuel, et al. (2002). The Gaon of Vilna: the man and his image (University of California Press) ISBN 0-520-22394-2
  • Etkes, Emanuel (1989). "The Gaon of Vilna and the Haskalah movement", by Emanuel Etkes, reprinted in Dan, Joseph (ed.). Studies in Jewish thought (Praeger, NY) ISBN 0-275-93038-6
  • Freedman, Chaim. Eliyahu's Branches: The Descendants of the Vilna Gaon (Of Blessed and Saintly Memory) and His Family (Avotaynu, 1997) ISBN 1-886223-06-8
  • "The mystical experiences of the Gaon of Vilna", in Jacobs, Louis (ed.). Jewish mystical testimonies (Schocken Books, NY, 1977) ISBN 0-8052-3641-4
  • Landau, Betzalel and Rosenblum, Yonason. The Vilna Gaon: the life and teachings of Rabbi Eliyahu, the Gaon of Vilna (Mesorah Pub., Ltd., 1994) ISBN 0-89906-441-8
  • Rosenstein, Neil. The Gaon of Vilna and his Cousinhood (Center for Jewish Genealogy, 1997) ISBN 0-9610578-5-8
  • Schapiro, Moshe. Journey of the Soul: The Vilna Gaon on Yonah/Johan: an allegorical commentary adapted from the Vilna Gaon's Aderes Eliyahu (Mesorah Pub., Ltd., 1997). ISBN 1-57819-161-0
  • Shulman, Yaacov Dovid. The Vilna Gaon: The story of Rabbi Eliyahu Kramer ( C.I.S. Publishers, 1994) ISBN 1-56062-278-4
[edit]